"Is Your Daughter Smart?" the Principal Asked

My Sweet, Funny, Kind (and Smart) Daughter



This is a somewhat warped tale about class, geography, race, wealth and bureaucratic bungling. As a private elementary school mom, I’m often asked why the Los Angeles private elementary school admission process is so competitive? Why are schools that charge up to $30,000 per year, per kid for elementary school receiving hundreds of applications for every open spot? Is L.A really overflowing with parents who are carefully orchestrating plans to steer their kids to the “right” private schools and then on to the Ivy League? Why are parents doing everything in their power (some of which is substantial) to get their kid admitted to a good private elementary school in L.A?


Depending on when you live in L.A. the public school system isn’t up to many parents’ standards. There are definitely some excellent public schools, but they vary by geographic location. Recent, severe public school budget cuts and scandals of epic proportion have driven even more parents to look at private schools as they confront increased class size, teacher layoffs and cuts in essential school services. The public school crisis has been on of the biggest factors keeping private school admissions competitive, despite the recession. I could easily turn this into a discussion about why too many public schools are failing our kids, but much has been written on that topic and I certainly don’t have the answers. 

As a product of L.A. public schools, I am intimately familiar with its many challenges. I experienced bullying, incompetent teachers and an uneven education. Naturally, I was seeking something better for my kids. I repeat, there are some excellent public schools in our city, it all comes back to the question of where you live. Does it make sense to buy a house you can’t really afford just to send your kid to public school in Bel Air?

The year before my daughter started elementary school, I wanted to put my public school memories behind me. After all, who had a great middle school experience anywhere?  So, I decided to look at our local public elementary school. It was three blocks from our house in Hancock Park, had high student test scores and seemed like a real possibility for my daughter. When the school’s computer lab was broken into the year before, I made a generous donation based on a letter sent to neighbors by the school. I was trying to keep an open mind, despite the fact that I only knew one neighbor who sent their kid there.  

Another mom at our preschool and I set up an appointment with to meet with the principal and tour the school . The day of our appointment we arrived on time just to learn that the principal was “unavailable.”  So, we waited, politely sitting in the front waiting area. Finally, after about 20 minutes the receptionist told us the principal wouldn’t be able to meet with us. We asked if a teacher could show us the school. A very nice kindergarten teacher gave us a quick tour and told us the principal was now available to see us in her office. We sat down and introduced ourselves. The principal seemed uninterested in us and bored with the conversation. We asked about class size, hot lunch and homework. Waving her hands and practically shouting us down, the principal didn’t answer our questions. Instead, she aimed a pointed question at me, “is your daughter smart?” she demanded to know. She didn’t ask the other mom the same question. My response was, “I live in your district.” In other words, you have to enroll my kid, whether or not she’s smart. I refused to answer her question. I found it offensive. We asked to see a 1st grade class. The principal said no. As we were leaving, the kindergarten teacher told us, “just be quiet, I’ll show you the 1st grade class.” We peeked into the 1st grade class and I suspected the reason why the principal didn’t want us to see it. It was a Korean-language immersion class. None of the kids in the class spoke English.  The principal was also Korean. Could she have been subtly trying to discourage me from enrolling my daughter in the school?

A few months later, I went back to the public school again during a school community fair. I tried to like it, but with 1000 elementary students, I felt my shy daughter might be lost in the crowd. And, I knew I wouldn’t be able to deal with the principal’s personality. The mom from our preschool who toured with me decided to enroll her child. Her perception of the school was vastly different than mine. Then again, the principal never asked if her white daughter was “smart.” That question was reserved for me, the African American mom.

Despite living in a “good” public school district, my husband and I decided private school would be the best option for our kids. And so began the hellish, ultra-competitive process to get our daughter into a top private elementary school in L.A.

In September 2005, we embarked on a time-consuming whirlwind of tours (10 schools), applications ($100 each), parent interviews, kid testing days, parent coffee chats, and then the agonizing waiting period in late March, as we held our breath to find out if our daughter had been accepted to private school. The LA Times dubbed the day the letters arrive as “Black Friday” because there are so many rejection lettersreceived, so much bad news for families who applied. On “Black Friday,” parents begin obsessively checking the mail, email, phone messages for any sign of admission letters. A fat envelope signals an acceptance. A thin, flat letter means rejection, or so the rumor goes. Stalking the mail truck, going to the school, drinking large quanties of wine, eating everything in sight and spending hours on the phone with girlfriends are just a few of the survival tactics my friends and I used until our letters arrived. When they ripped open their letters, overjoyed parents have admitted to running crazily into the middle of the street shouting to everyone they know that their kid got into private school. A bunch of “no” letters sent one mom friend of mine into the closet for a tear-filled, drinking binge, devastated that her child was denied admission everywhere she applied. I felt the process was very personal. You’ve put your entire family on the line for admissions directors to evaluate. The parent interviews are like a job interview that includes your 4 or 5 year old’s “resume.”

“You have to ‘work it’ to get your kid into private school,” I heard over and over from everyone. What did that mean? I filled out the applications, dragged my husband to the interviews with a strict warning to leave his sarcastic sense of humor at home, had my daughter tested, attended school events.  What else could I do? Well, there was more to do, I just didn’t know it. About two weeks before letters arrived, I found out through the parent grapevine that there is an entire “behind the scenes” process that is happening during admissions season. Parents who told me, “I’d never ask a parent at the school where we’re applying to write me a letter of recommendation” were not telling the truth. Everyone was getting letters from anybody they knew who was remotely connected to the private schools. Some parents have been known to go up the food chain seeking letters from U.S. Senators and Ambassadors. These types also send fancy gifts to admissions directors. Upon learning this, I scrambled to asked several families we knew to write letters on our behalf. Luckily, they wrote the letters, which at minimum eased my mind and at best helped my daughter get into all three schools we applied to. 

My daughter is now about to enter 5th grade. Was all the stress of admissions worth it?  Absolutely. But, private schools aren’t perfect either, although their challenges are different than public schools. They are insanely expensive and tuition rises 4-8 percent per year. On top of tuition, there are other costs, like annual giving and “extras” for your kid. There is also elitism and privilege like I’ve never seen before. Not surprisingly, there are very few working class or lower middle class families. The term “I’ll give you a ride” doesn’t necessarily mean a car ride. It can also mean a ride on somebody’s PRIVATE JET.

Because the admissions process was so stressful and there was so much “off the radar” networking happening, I collaborated with two educators (one of them is my step mom) to write a book about navigating the private school process. I also blog about it because I believe parents who wants a private school education for their child should have access to information that is accessible to some families, but not all. In order to play the game, you must understand its hidden rules.

I’m grateful my kids are at a progressive urban private school. I know we are fortunate to be able to pay the cost of their education. We also make this a financial priority in our family, in part because of my negative experience in LA public schools. My husband attended top public suburban schools outside Philadelphia so he doesn’t completely grasp the idea that public school isn’t an option. We contribute to our school’s scholarship fund to help finance diverse families who can’t pay the full tuition. On days when I’ve come across a particularly entitled, snobbish parent, I wonder if I made the right choice. Then again I don’t think the suburbs are for me.

Six years after the public school principal demanded to know if my daughter was “smart” I can tell her she didn’t need to worry. The answer is yes. She’s also sweet, funny and kind. 

* First published on Open Salon


We post stuff on our Facebook Page that isn’t on the blog…click on Facebook

admin

Christina Simon: Los Angeles, California, United States I'm the mom of a daughter (15) and a son (12) who attend Viewpoint School in Calabasas. I live in Coldwater Canyon with my family and a rescue pit bull, Cocoa. Contact me at csimon2007@gmail.com

11 thoughts on “"Is Your Daughter Smart?" the Principal Asked

  1. My kid went to 3rd St. It didn't matter at all to the powers that ran it that my daughter was actually "smart," since there was no enrichment to offer her. The school did, however, benefit greatly from her annual high test scores in terms of reputation. And yeah, that principal rubs a lot of people the wrong way.

  2. Wow! Hard to believe the insensitivity and rudeness of such a question, and the process sounds insane and not that far off the experiences here. We have a middle ground of lottery-based charter schools here in NYC that are generally much better than most public ones (there are some great public ones, and yes here too ppl live where they can't afford to in order to get in) and the process to get into those is very similar, I was appalled to find the behind the scenes game as crazy as it was. Honestly that ended up being part of the reason I ended up homeschooling, which isn't for everyone by any means but works well for us right now. Thanks for a great look at the whole process, and the info you provide on your site is fabulous for those going through it after you!

  3. Christina, thank you for all you do in helping those of us on the road to elementary school applications. I have learned SO much from your book & blog and feel much more confident that, at the very least, I am putting our best feet forward as a family. Not only that, I also feel as though I have a much better sense of what I am looking for in a school and it is not just that it be "the best". The warts & all approach you take is so appreciated.
    Thank you!
    -Gina

  4. This brought back so many painful memories, LOL!
    I had no clue that entry into private school was so competitive, until we applied to one single school and got rejected! Actually, I don't think It resonated with me then how competitive it was, until we reapplied the following year and got wait listed! with no other options (because we naively only applied to one school)I begged and cried my way off the waitlist!
    Now our child is approaching middle school years and we are entering that application process.

    Applying for Middle School is way more stressful that elementary apps. By this stage of the game, your child is a real person, with real opinions and ideas. If your child does not present well at a MS interview, or blows it with a quirky comment, it's "exit stage left" and don't come back!

    …….and, almost everybody in the MS application process is secretive & furtive. Parents who a year ago enjoyed each others' company over backyard BBQ, are now avowed MS applicant adversaries. OY!

  5. Christina,
    Is there any way we could have a Middle School thread?

    There was one about the consortium evening a few months back, but that was fairly generic.

    It would be great if somehow we could have something here, for those of us just embarking on this process of ISEEs, applications, tours etc.

    Thanks

  6. Hi Anon, I'd like to have more information about the MS process, but I haven't been through it myself. I will ask Anne if she'd like to write about MS admissions since she was dean of Crossroads MS. Stay tuned…

    Thanks for your comment!

  7. That's great. Thanks, Christina.

    Westside options seem to be shrinking, I recently learned that Crossroads is expanding its 6th grade, therefore leaving fewer 7th grade openings, and this year, another Westside 7-12 is offering early application/interview preference to applicants from 3 other westside Tier 1 elementary schools.

    Ugh! College admissions are easier than this!

  8. What an inappropriate question for the principal to ask! Although I can imagine she might really have been trying to dissuade you from enrolling your daughter, given the demographics of the school.

    I stopped by a nearby charter school once, being interested in alternatives to neighborhood public school. The principal came out and chatted with me for a minute, looking surprised that I walked in. Then she asked, "You do know that this is a Spanish immersion school?"

  9. Hello Christina,
    We are at the beginning of the elementary process, and I am thankful for your blog and your insights. I just pray and hope for the best, while I make sure to "do the right things" as outlined in your book. Thank you again for a valuable community service!

  10. The more things change, the more they stay the same. It’s 2014 and things are pretty much still the same as you wrote back in 2011. I applied to private schools for my child, and in less than 3 weeks, we’ll know where we’ve been accepted. I say “we’ve” because these schools aren’t just looking at the kid, they’re looking at the whole family! I wish there were greater emphasis on selecting each child for who he or she is, rather than who his or her family is. Anyway, thanks for the always relevant and interesting blog.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>